On Tuesday night’s episode of The Voice, contestant Terrence Cunningham proved you don’t have to be flashy to turn all four coaches’ chairs during a blind audition. The talented singer chose to sing a mellow version of The Temptations’ “My Girl” while playing the keyboard.

His unique take on the classic was so captivating, it prompted all four coaches to turn their chairs around after only the first few lines. “I think we’re all a little bit speechless right now,” Blake Shelton said when the performance was finished. “I’ve never heard a performance like that at any level of The Voice.” [READ MORE]